Our Pick: The Best Cream Eyeshadows Worth Trying

Jun 16, 2021
06:00 P.M.
Share this pen

Herald the innovative formulas that are easy to blend, settle comfortably on your eyes, and rate sky-high on the wearability scale. Yes, we’re talking about the cream eyeshadows, which are a miracle reveal for people with dry and oily eyelids.


An eyeshadow that stays put all day and all night long and doesn’t budge or crease isn’t hard to find anymore. Thanks to all the tried and tested options emerging in the market, you can now find your no touch-up eye BFF sooner than later.

If you’re tired of powder eyeshadows leaving your eyes like a wrinkled pothole, perhaps it’s time to turn to a creamy formula instead. And now that we have you almost convinced, it’s worth scrolling down to find the best cream eyeshadows for your super glowy, vibrant eye makeover.

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow


Price: $29

This cult-classic multi-purpose eyeshadow stick is available in three finishes: Shimmer, Matte, and Metallic. It’s a long-wear formula that will enable you to nail a myriad of different looks, be it the classy smokey eye or a glittery pop of color.

Maybelline New York Eyestudio ColorTattoo Metal

Price: $4


Are you looking for an eyeshadow that lasts you from breakfast till after dinner? Look no further than Maybelline New York’s Eyestudio ColorTattoo Metal, available in 16 highly buildable shades and three finishes: Shimmery, Glitter, and Metallic.

Charlotte Tilbury Eyes To Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow


Price: $32

Glam up your eyes with the gorgeous Eyes To Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow by the cult fave brand Charlotte Tilbury. This long-lasting, non-creasing eyeshadow has a soft, shimmery finish and is infused with vitamin E to keep your eyes looking dreamy.

Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow

Price: $5.07


Revlon’s Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow is designed to blend super fast, offering a smooth, buttery texture that will never budge or dry. Available in matte and shimmer finishes, you can choose from 18 exciting shades and ace your eye makeup goals for up to 24 hours straight.

Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

Price: $24

Stila’s Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow is a long-lasting formula, available in 11 gorgeous shades. It’s easy to apply and blends seamlessly to give an incredible sparkly and glittery finish to your eyes.


Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint

Jillian Dempsey’s Lid Tint is perfect for adding an instant color pop to your eyes. This highly pigmented and super blendable tint comes in 10 stunning shades, so choose the one that makes your eyes glow and shine.

About Face Matte Fluid Eye Paint



Price: $24

Halsey’s beauty label About Face is known for its rich and pigmented makeup products, including highlighters, eyeliners, and lipgloss. The Matte Fluid Eye Paint is a highly buildable, buttery smooth formula that glides effortlessly to give a bold, vibrant look.